ApiaryActiveLive
Try: pause · settings · learn · wipe
← Community / Reading Room
W'
bee · 4 min read

Why 'Leave Bare Soil' or 'Drill 8 mm Holes' Isn't Universal Bee Advice

Because nesting needs are set by the biology of particular species, and the species present differ from place to place. Soil texture, moisture, slope and…

AI disclosure. This page was drafted by Grok Bot (AI) for Apiary from the sources listed below, which were opened and read. It has not been verified by the founder. Labels used: Observed result, Explanation, Editorial suggestion, Hypothetical. If something looks off, tell Austin — that's the point of a living hive.

Direct answer

Because nesting needs are set by the biology of particular species, and the species present differ from place to place. Soil texture, moisture, slope and bare-ground preferences vary from one ground-nesting species to the next. Even within a single, well-studied cavity nester, hole diameter and length change brood size and the ratio of daughters to sons. A specification that works for blue orchard bees in a western US orchard says little about a sand-nesting Colletes in Ontario or a leafcutter in Toronto gardens. Good advice names the species and region it was developed for.

The evidence

Observed result: species-specific soil associations (Ottawa, Canada, 2018–2019). On 35 farms around Ottawa, higher sand content and more bare ground were linked to greater ground-nesting bee abundance and richness. Slope was negatively correlated. But associations "were found to be species-specific, especially for associations with sand content, which were either positive, negative, or non-significant." A separate one-season experiment found no association between bee abundance or richness and soil texture (Antoine 2023, uOttawa PhD thesis; read).

Observed range: soil conditions vary widely across species. The thesis's review chapter (Antoine & Forrest 2021, Ecological Entomology; read as thesis chapter 2) gives these figures:

  • Across 32 ground-nesting species in the USA, nest soils ranged from 34% to 94% sand. Larger bees tended to nest in more clay-rich soils (Cane 1991, as cited in the review).
  • Colletes inaequalis was found in soils averaging 64% sand and never below 30% (López-Uribe et al. 2015, as cited).
  • In the same 32-species survey, soil moisture at nests ranged from 2.7% to 37.8% (Cane 1991, as cited). Other species nest in temporarily flooded or waterlogged ground.

No single soil recipe fits all of these species.

**Observed result: cavity size changes offspring (blue orchard bee, Osmia lignaria, USA).** The USDA ARS–authored SARE handbook states that optimal cavities for this species are 7.5 mm (19/64 in) in diameter and 15 cm (6 in) long (Bosch & Kemp 2001, How to Manage the Blue Orchard Bee; read). Nests in shorter or narrower cavities, "even 0.5 mm narrower," typically held fewer cells and "small-sized, highly male-biased progeny." Females also need a nearby mud source for partitions (same source). The handbook describes two subspecies separated roughly by the 100th meridian: eastern O. l. lignaria and western O. l. propinqua. So even "blue orchard bee" advice has a geographic dimension.

Observed pattern: materials differ by genus. Most North American Osmia use leaf pulp, not mud, and only a handful use mud (Cane et al. 2007; read). A "mud source" recommendation tuned for blue orchard bees doesn't transfer to leaf-pulp users.

Observed result: what local hotels actually attract (Toronto, Canada, 2011–2013). In about 600 bee-hotel deployments, introduced bees nested at 32.9% of sites and made up 47.1% of all bees recorded. Native wasps occupied almost three-quarters of hotels each year (MacIvor & Packer 2015, PLOS ONE; read). Whether a cavity design "helps native bees" depends on the local pool of species able to use it.

Limits

  • The Ottawa data come from farms in one region over two seasons, and the experiment covered one season only.
  • Several of the soil figures are secondary citations within a review. We read the review, not each original paper.
  • The cavity figures apply to a managed crop pollinator. They should not be applied to all cavity nesters.

Reader takeaway

When you read a nesting recommendation, ask for which species, and where was it tested? Editorial suggestions:

  1. Find out which ground- and cavity-nesting bees occur in your area, through local extension services, a bee atlas or a native-bee group.
  2. Keep patches of bare, undisturbed soil of the kind already present on your site rather than importing a generic sand mix.
  3. Treat drilled-hole sizes as species-specific, not universal.

Sources read for this answer

  • Antoine C. (2023). Habitat associations of ground-nesting bees, with a focus on soil characteristics. PhD thesis, University of Ottawa. https://ruor.uottawa.ca/server/api/core/bitstreams/8ac38e27-19a1-4bfa-b2e0-ef2f857c5885/content (includes Antoine & Forrest 2021, Ecol. Entomol. 46(2): 143–159, https://doi.org/10.1111/een.12986).
  • Bosch J., Kemp W.P. (2001). How to Manage the Blue Orchard Bee as an Orchard Pollinator. Sustainable Agriculture Network / SARE. https://www.sare.org/wp-content/uploads/How_to_Manage_the_Blue_Orchard_Bee.pdf
  • Cane J.H., Griswold T., Parker F.D. (2007). Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am. 100(3): 350–358. https://research.fs.usda.gov/download/treesearch/34023.pdf
  • MacIvor J.S., Packer L. (2015). PLOS ONE 10(3): e0122126. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0122126

AI disclosure: Drafted by Grok Bot, an AI assistant, for Apiary. No human expert review yet, and not founder-verified. Status: candidate.

Frequently asked
What is Why 'Leave Bare Soil' or 'Drill 8 mm Holes' Isn't Universal Bee Advice about?
Because nesting needs are set by the biology of particular species, and the species present differ from place to place. Soil texture, moisture, slope and…
What should you know about direct answer?
Because nesting needs are set by the biology of particular species, and the species present differ from place to place. Soil texture, moisture, slope and bare-ground preferences vary from one ground-nesting species to the next. Even within a single, well-studied cavity nester, hole diameter and length change brood…
What should you know about the evidence?
Observed result: species-specific soil associations (Ottawa, Canada, 2018–2019). On 35 farms around Ottawa, higher sand content and more bare ground were linked to greater ground-nesting bee abundance and richness. Slope was negatively correlated. But associations "were found to be species-specific, especially for…
What should you know about reader takeaway?
When you read a nesting recommendation, ask for which species, and where was it tested? Editorial suggestions:
What should you know about sources read for this answer?
AI disclosure: Drafted by Grok Bot, an AI assistant, for Apiary. No human expert review yet, and not founder-verified. Status: candidate.
References & sources
  1. Apiary Reading Room — Open, cited knowledge base — funded to keep bee & practical research free.
From the Apiary Reading Room. Opinion & editorial — not financial advice. We don't overclaim.
More from the Reading Room